I am totally ripping off the title of the post that inspired me to write. Because it's true, and very few people, even within the LGBT community, know just how expensive it is. I'll admit that, while I knew it was more costly to be a married same-sex couple than a married hetero couple, I never really broke it down.
Christina laid it out in ways that I can only steal because I'm not married yet, and because, honestly, a lot of this stuff either goes over my head or puts me into a coma. There are 1,138 rights, protections and benefits that couples get when their marriage is recognized by the federal government. Some don't really affect us, like immigration issues. Some are a bit complicated however: if for some reason I had to go onto Ellie's medical plan, we would be lucky enough to pay the same rate as a hetero married couple because MA recognizes our marriage. When April 15 comes rolling around though, Ellie would have to pay federal taxes on the "extra income" she is receiving from her company for covering her "unmarried partner." Being the former HR person that I am, I'll try to explain it for you other non-math people (hypothetical numbers here):
If she ever convinces me that having a child is a good idea, we get into an even bigger set of drama--only one of us is biologically the mother. Sure, I can be added to the birth certificate since we are lucky enough to live in MA, but here comes that pesky DOMA conundrum again--other states don't have to recognize it! This means yet MORE money, time and hassle going through second-parent adoption, iron-clad wills. Christina said is very succinctly: It’s hard not to resent that a guy just has to have an orgasm to get full parental rights, and we get the legal and financial runaround." This is all on top of the cost to actually conceive the baby--no, Ellie's not going to "do it the traditional way"--even if she did, it would cost money to work up the contracts with the bio-father, and we would always have a risk of him wanting the child, and getting it because we're gay.
About the only good thing DOMA is doing for us? My federal school loan payments are income-based, and since the feds won't consider us married, only my measly income is counted in the calculation of how much I have to pay. If we were married, both of our measly incomes would be counted, resulting in much higher payments.
I still think I'd take marriage equality.
![]() |
| Us at her brother's wedding; personal photo |
Ellie's job pays $100/month towards the cost of a family plan. If she was on a single plan, they would only be paying $25/month. The "extra" $75/month her company is "giving" to her is taxable because it's not actually covering her married dependent, so the feds tax it.Shitty, huh? So, I'm on Ellie's insurance, but we're on vacation in Florida and I get attacked by a shark. Even if we've paid a lawyer thousands of dollars (to get it done right) to create, notarize and file paperwork allowing her to visit me & make decisions on my behalf, that hospital can deny her access and allow me to die alone.
If she ever convinces me that having a child is a good idea, we get into an even bigger set of drama--only one of us is biologically the mother. Sure, I can be added to the birth certificate since we are lucky enough to live in MA, but here comes that pesky DOMA conundrum again--other states don't have to recognize it! This means yet MORE money, time and hassle going through second-parent adoption, iron-clad wills. Christina said is very succinctly: It’s hard not to resent that a guy just has to have an orgasm to get full parental rights, and we get the legal and financial runaround." This is all on top of the cost to actually conceive the baby--no, Ellie's not going to "do it the traditional way"--even if she did, it would cost money to work up the contracts with the bio-father, and we would always have a risk of him wanting the child, and getting it because we're gay.
About the only good thing DOMA is doing for us? My federal school loan payments are income-based, and since the feds won't consider us married, only my measly income is counted in the calculation of how much I have to pay. If we were married, both of our measly incomes would be counted, resulting in much higher payments.
I still think I'd take marriage equality.




